| Winner |
Homestate |
Year |
Runner-Up |
| Natalie Blonien |
Oklahoma |
2024 |
Harlow Gregory |
| Natalie Blonien |
Oklahoma |
2023 |
Alisha Rametra |
| Emerson Purcell |
Ohio |
2022 |
Alli Reily |
| Alexis Escobedo |
Texas |
2021 |
Brecklyn Flanagan |
| Alexis Escobedo |
Texas |
2019 |
Meg Brown |
| ShaeBug Scarberry |
Oklahoma |
2018 |
Faith Delagarza |
| ShaeBug Scarberry |
Oklahoma |
2017 |
Summer Marshall |
| ShaeBug Scarberry |
Oklahoma |
2016 |
Alexis Read |
| Savanah Snyder |
Texas |
2015 |
Caylee Senn |
| Sarah Moore |
Texas |
2014 |
Carolina Rotzinger |
| Sarah Moore |
Texas |
2013 |
Ali Cowan |
| Megan Blonien |
Oklahoma |
2012 |
Marla Souvannasing |
| Megan Blonien |
Oklahoma |
2011 |
April McCoy |
| Sammi Stevens |
Texas |
2010 |
Alexandra Rossi |
| Sammi Stevens |
Texas |
2009 |
Taylor Moreno |
| Kayland Carson |
Texas |
2008 |
Brittany Smith |
| Maury Shock |
|
2007 |
Chandra Alexander |
| Brittany Tomerlin |
Texas |
2006 |
Kelsey Vines |
| Daphne Vines |
Texas |
2005 |
Lisa Ann McClosky |
| Kate Hathaway |
Texas |
2004 |
Lauren Olaya |
| Stefanie Page |
Texas |
2003 |
Kelly Louth |
| Christine Fernandez |
Nevada |
2002 |
Mallory Underwood |
| Violeta Retamoza |
Mexico |
2001 |
Brook Tull |
| Lisa Tyler |
Florida |
2000 |
Mary Fernandez |
| Yunuen Sanchez |
Mexico |
1999 |
Maiko Senda |
| Kim Rowton |
Texas |
1998 |
Meredith Duncan |
| Randi Meadows |
Texas |
1997 |
Stacy Prammanasudh |
| Reilly Rankin |
Hilton Head, S.C. |
1996 |
Angela Stanford |
| Reilly Rankin |
Hilton Head, S.C. |
1995 |
Kim Rowton |
| Kelli Kuehne |
Texas |
1994 |
Lea Albert |
| Holly Carriker |
Texas |
1993 |
Tiyun Lee |
| Kelli Kuehne |
Texas |
1992 |
Victoria Boysen |
| Holly Carriker |
Texas |
1991 |
J.J. Rorie |
| Wendy Ward |
Texas |
1990 |
Lisa Balch |
| Tina Trimble |
Texas |
1989 |
Kay Donalson |
| Sandy Hamby |
Texas |
1988 |
Laura Myers |
| Kathy Moore |
Texas |
1987 |
Bronwyn Burke |
| Kathy Moore |
Texas |
1986 |
Adele Moore |
| Adele Moore |
Texas |
1985 |
Mia Browning |
| Buffi Kline |
Texas |
1984 |
Angie Ravioli |
